Conservation New

Energy transformations and their environmental impacts

Decide which energy transformations have the greatest environmental impacts on the environment.

Grade

Duration

30 mins

Type

Class discussion

Overview

Inevitably, energy transformations impact the environment. Through co-creating a criteria and analyzing everyday examples, students decide which energy transformations have the greatest impacts on the environment.

Instructions
Curriculum fit

Instructions

What you'll need

"Rating the environmental impacts of energy transformations" worksheet

Begin the activity by inviting your students to make a decision: Which has more environmental impact, a gas-powered or electric vehicle? As students begin to make their decision, prompt them to focus on the energy transformations associated with each vehicle.
Invite students to share their decisions and thinking with the class. As they share, use their ideas to co-develop or present the criteria for an important environmental impact. The criteria could include:

Depth: the impacts have deep or serious effects on natural environments
Breadth: the impacts have effects on many parts of natural environments
Duration: the impacts on natural environments are long-lasting

Note and display the criteria for use later in this activity.

Organize your students into small groups and provide each group with a copy of the "Rating the environmental impacts of energy transformations" worksheet. Briefly explain that their challenge is to select a pair of devices and decide which has the greatest impact on the environment. Examples of possible options include:

Gas powered vehicles versus electric powered vehicles
Hybrid vehicles versus electric powered vehicles
Hybrid vehicles versus gas powered vehicles
Gas powered furnace versus electric powered furnace
Gas powered stove versus electric powered stove

Prompt groups to note the energy transformations associated with each of their selected options on the activity sheet. Student suggestions could include:

Chemical energy → mechanical energy: gas powered vehicle
Electrical energy → mechanical energy: electric powered vehicle

After groups have noted the energy transformations, ask them to use the rating scale to rate the overall environmental impacts of the energy transformations. Remind groups to use the criteria to guide their thinking.
Invite groups to share their ratings with the class. As groups share, invite the class to look for commonalities among the ratings: Which types of energy transformations have the greatest impacts on the environment? The least? How could we learn about promoting energy conservation and sustainability from these commonalities?

Modify or extend this activity

Modification

For ELL students, consider using word walls or vocabulary sheets to help them develop understanding of the science terms used in the lesson.
Incorporate a variety of learning styles within the lesson (e.g., auditory through the discussion that happens, visual through the images displayed on board, reading/writing through recording their thoughts on paper, kinesthetic through hands-on activities).

Extension

In addition to having groups rating the environmental impacts, using their assigned or selected device, ask groups to assess the environmental impacts of the entire lifecycle of the device (i.e., production, use, disposal).